When Kimmy creates an online dating profile for D.J., she meets Tyler. Kimmy brings him to the house to meet D.J. When D.J. finds Tyler standing in the living room she believes he is the plummer come to fix the clogged toilet. D.J. takes him to the upstairs bathroom and he starts to take his shirt off, he thinks she wants him to get started in the shower. When D.J. asks what kind of plumber is he, Tyler thinks she is role playing and replies a 'naughty plumber', and she is the lonely neurosurgeon. That's when Kimmy walks in with the real plumber, and explains who Tyler really is.