|Air Date||December 9, 2016|
|Total Ep #||23|
|Previous||Glazed and Confused|
|Next||DJ and Kimmy's High School Reunion|
Kimmy buys concert tickets to New Kids on the Block for D.J.'s 39th birthday, but when she and Stephanie discover that the tickets are counterfeit, they attempt to make it up to D.J. by bringing the band to the house. Max cooks up a painful twist that changes everything.
- Scott Weinger as Steve Hale
- John Brotherton as Matt Harmon
- New Kids on the Block
- Jim Titus as Driver
- Yolanda English as Concert Goer
- DJ's birthday would be in December if you follow the sequence of events. In the original series, D.J.'s birthday was said to be February 9, 1977.
- Donnie Wahlberg was unable to join his New Kids on the Block band-mates on set for this episode, as he was filming his show Blue Bloods at the time. But he can be seen via an iPad, singing 'happy birthday' to D.J.
- 'Happy Birthday' performed by New Kids on the Block
- 'Please Don't Go Girl' performed by New Kids on the Block
- 'You Got It (The Right Stuff)' performed by New Kids on the Block